Compare ETFs

Select two ETFs to analyze their holdings overlap and correlation

Popular Comparisons

SPY vs QQQ
SPY vs VOO
QQQ vs VTI
VTI vs VOO
XLK vs VGT
EFA vs VEA
AGG vs BND
IWM vs VTI
XLE vs XLF

Browse by Category

What Is ETF Overlap?

ETF overlap measures the percentage of holdings shared between two exchange-traded funds. When you hold multiple ETFs, overlap tells you how much genuine diversification you are actually getting versus simply paying double fees for the same stocks.

For example, SPY (S&P 500) and VOO (S&P 500) share 99.8% of their holdings — they are virtually identical. Holding both provides zero extra diversification and costs you two expense ratios. By contrast, VOO (US stocks) and AGG (US bonds) have 0% overlap — they are true complements that smooth portfolio volatility.

EigenDex calculates overlap by comparing the actual holdings of each ETF and computing the weighted intersection — how much of your combined portfolio is exposed to the same underlying companies.

How Much ETF Overlap Is Too Much?

A useful rule of thumb:

  • 0–30% overlap: Excellent. The two ETFs provide meaningfully different exposures.
  • 30–60% overlap: Moderate. Some redundancy, but the ETFs still serve different roles.
  • 60–80% overlap: High. Consider whether both ETFs are necessary in your portfolio.
  • 80–100% overlap: Near-duplicate. You are almost certainly paying double fees for the same positions.

Common high-overlap traps include: SPY + VOO (99.8%), QQQ + VGT (86%), and VTI + VOO (82%). None of these pairs provide meaningful diversification from each other.

Why ETF Overlap Matters for Your Portfolio

Hidden overlap creates three specific problems for investors:

  1. Concentration risk: If you hold SPY, QQQ, and VGT, your effective technology allocation can exceed 50% of your portfolio — far beyond what most investors intend. A single sector downturn wipes out gains across all three funds simultaneously.
  2. Wasted expense ratios: Every overlapping dollar pays two management fees. An investor holding $100,000 split between SPY (0.09%) and VOO (0.03%) on identical stocks pays $60/year more than simply choosing one fund.
  3. False diversification: Owning five ETFs does not mean owning five distinct strategies. Many popular ETF combinations overlap substantially because the US large-cap market dominates global indices.

How to Build a Low-Overlap Portfolio

The classic three-fund portfolio minimizes overlap by combining asset classes that are structurally different:

  • US Total Market (VTI or VOO): Broad US equity exposure, ~0.03% expense ratio.
  • International Developed (VXUS or VEA): Non-US stocks — virtually 0% overlap with VTI.
  • US Bonds (BND or AGG): Bonds have 0% overlap with equities and reduce volatility.

If you want sector or factor tilts, choose ETFs that complement rather than duplicate your base. Adding XLV (healthcare) to VTI adds targeted exposure. Adding QQQ to SPY mostly doubles down on tech.

Use the ETF comparison tool above to check the overlap percentage between any two funds before adding them to your portfolio. A quick check takes 10 seconds and can save years of suboptimal returns.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does ETF overlap affect returns?

Overlap itself does not change returns — both ETFs still track their underlying indices. The issue is that high overlap means you are paying multiple expense ratios for the same performance, and you may be taking on more concentration risk than you realize without getting compensating diversification benefits.

Is 50% overlap between two ETFs a problem?

It depends on the context. SPY and QQQ share about 56% overlap, yet many investors hold both intentionally — SPY for broad market exposure and QQQ for extra tech/growth weighting. The question to ask is: am I adding this ETF because it gives me exposure I want, or just because I like the name?

How is ETF overlap calculated?

Overlap is typically calculated as the sum of the minimum weights for each stock present in both ETFs. If Apple is 7% of ETF A and 12% of ETF B, Apple contributes 7% to the overlap calculation. The result is the share of your combined investment that is exposed to the same underlying positions.

Which ETF pairs have zero overlap?

ETF pairs with 0% overlap are typically from entirely different asset classes: US stocks vs. bonds (VOO and BND), US equities vs. commodity ETFs (VTI and GLD), or broad equities vs. single-sector inverse ETFs. Within equities, it is nearly impossible to have 0% overlap if both ETFs hold US large-cap stocks.